Question of the Day for High School Students: 200+ Prompts

Teen boy grabbing snack next to laptop in kitchen

High school students can handle big questions, often better than we give them credit for. Ask a teenager whether it’s ever right to break an unjust law, and you may be surprised by how carefully they think it through. Many are hungry to talk about things that matter. They just need someone to ask.

Our free Question of the Day for High School Students offers more than 200 questions drawn from the Great Books, history, science, mathematics, Scripture, and the arts, along with lighter questions for days when a room needs warming up. Use one as a bell ringer, a journal prompt, or a dinner table conversation, and watch where it leads.

Today’s question Thursday, November 19

Literature · Discussion

What is the most important choice a character makes in a book you have read?

How to Use the Question of the Day in High School

The tool above opens with today’s question. Filter by kind and length, shuffle for something new, or display the question on screen for your class. The planner fills a run of school days with questions you can lock, swap, or replace with your own, and it prints as a weekly schedule or as single pages to post.

A few ways to put it to work:

  • Bell ringer. Students answer in writing during the first three minutes of class, then two or three share aloud.
  • Thesis practice. Ask students to answer the day’s question in a single arguable sentence, then support it with two reasons.
  • Seminar warm-up. A Great Ideas question can open a Socratic discussion before you turn to the text.
  • Commonplace book or journal. Over a semester, a collection of answers becomes a record of how a student’s thinking has grown.
  • Family conversation. Teenagers who don’t say much about their day will often talk for a long time about a good question.

Why Big Questions Matter for Teenagers

The high school years are when students begin forming convictions of their own. Classical educators call this the rhetoric stage, when a young person longs to express what they believe and to do it persuasively (The Trivium Explained). A daily question gives that longing a steady place to practice.

These questions also invite students into a conversation much older than they are. At his trial, Socrates told the jury that the unexamined life is not worth living (Plato, Apology). Aristotle asked what makes a person happy. Augustine wrote that our hearts are restless until they rest in God. When a student wrestles with the same questions, they discover that the great thinkers of the past are still worth talking to.

A good question invites a teenager into a conversation that has been going on for three thousand years.

The Kinds of Questions You’ll Find

  • Casual: “If you could have been an apprentice to anyone in history, whom would you choose?”
  • Great Ideas: “Is it better for a leader to be feared or loved?”
  • History: “Was Brutus a traitor or a patriot?”
  • Literature: “Was Antigone right to defy King Creon?”
  • Science: “Is a good experiment one that proves you right or one that could prove you wrong?”
  • Math and Logic: “Can something be true but impossible to prove?”
  • Theology: “Is doubt the opposite of faith?”
  • Art and Music: “Why do you think so much great art comes out of hard times?”

Many questions include a short note “for the conversation,” pointing to the source behind the question, such as Machiavelli’s The Prince, Sophocles’ Antigone, or Kurt Gödel’s work on proof, so you can guide the discussion without hours of preparation.

Turning a Question into a Conversation

It can be discouraging to bring a question you care about into a room of tired teenagers and hear nothing back. Many teachers and parents know that feeling well. Often the quiet comes from uncertainty more than disinterest: students aren’t yet sure the adult really wants their honest answer.

Show that you want their real answer. Resist the urge to steer toward the “right” one. Ask “Why do you think so?” and listen to the reasoning.

Let disagreement breathe. When two students disagree, invite each to state the other’s view fairly before responding. Teenagers learn a great deal from seeing disagreement handled with charity.

Give them time. Researcher Mary Budd Rowe found that when teachers waited three seconds or more after asking a question, students gave longer and more thoughtful answers (“Wait Time: Slowing Down May Be a Way of Speeding Up,” Journal of Teacher Education, 1986).

Think out loud with them. Share your own answer and where you’re still unsure. Students take more risks when the adult does too.

For more on leading rich discussions, see What Is the Socratic Method? and 3 Reasons Why Deep Discussions Are Critically Important.

Where These Questions Come From

Many of these questions grow out of the books high school students at Veritas Press read every year: Homer and Sophocles, Augustine and Dante, Shakespeare and Austen. In our Omnibus courses, each reading comes with a “Question to Consider,” one big question that frames the discussion and gives students something worth defending (Leading Omnibus Discussions: The Importance of the Question to Consider). If your student enjoys these questions, the Great Books are a wonderful place to keep going (The Great Books: Why They Matter and How to Teach Them).

Give your teen great books and great conversations

Explore Omnibus, or see how high school works at Veritas Scholars Academy.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are good questions of the day for high school students?

The best ones are open, within reach, and worth arguing about. Questions like “What is the difference between knowledge and wisdom?” or “Should we do something just because science makes it possible?” give students room to think and to disagree thoughtfully.

How do I use a question of the day as a bell ringer?

Display the question as students arrive using “Show on screen.” Give them two or three minutes to write a response, then invite a few to share. Quick questions work well when time is short, and discussion questions can lead into the day’s lesson.

Are these questions only for Christian schools?

The questions come from a classical Christian perspective, and the Theology questions draw on Scripture. If you’d like to focus on other kinds, simply turn Theology off in the filters.

Can I add my own questions to the schedule?

Yes. Select the pencil icon on any day in the planner to write your own. Your question is locked in place so reshuffling won’t replace it, and everything saves in your browser.