Microschools: Don Soifer on a Growing Option for Families

Episode 217 · November 17, 2026 · 31 min Homeschooling

About this episode

Microschools are one of the fastest-growing options in education today. Don Soifer joins Marlin Detweiler to talk about what microschools are, why so many families are choosing them, and what parents should consider before joining or starting one.

Share this episode

Enjoyed it? Rate Vox on Apple Podcasts.

Full transcript

Note: This transcription may vary from the words used in the original episode.

Marlin Detweiler:
Hello again. Welcome to another episode of Veritas Vox, the voice of classical Christian education. Today we have with us Don Soifer. It’s a tough name for those that aren’t German, but I am, so I know how to say this. It’s good to have you here, Don.

Don Soifer:
Thanks so much for having me. A big fan and I love everything that you’ve done in Belgium.

Marlin Detweiler:

Well thank you.

Give us we’re going to talk a little bit about an idea that might be helpful to many of our constituents, called microschools, that are somewhere between a school and a home school, probably leaning more towards the homeschool world. But before we do that, give us a little background of your career, education, and family. To provide some context for why you’re doing what you’re doing.

Don Soifer:
Thanks, Marlin. We are a microschool family ourselves. We’ve got three microschool high school kids who in the past have been in three different microschools. When everything shut down earlier in this decade, we were running an education nonprofit in Nevada. And as far as I was concerned, it was all hands on deck for education.

So I was in with the mayor of the poorest, hardest working, fastest growing city in Nevada when everything shut down around him. And including the school district, including the charter schools, including the private schools. And so I worked my background is as an education researcher. I’ve worked in sort of innovative school environments and unintended consequences of systems for a long time.

So I knew and had written about my schooling, and we dropped what we were doing. We donated our time, and the city gave us their rec centers and libraries, and we created a public private partnership microschool with city appropriated dollars to hire teams, served 125 kids, three quarters of whom were more than two grade levels, behind which in micro you celebrate low baselines, of course, because that’s exactly who we wanted to be serving.

And then suddenly we got a lot of good coverage in the Nevada media, and we had 25 people meeting at our office on Thursday nights to learn how to start a microschool. So some of the foundations that we’d gotten to know assess. Do you want to take the show on the road? And we now work with thousands of microschools in all 50 states.

Marlin Detweiler:
Wow. So let’s not assume anything. Let’s define our terms. What is a microschool?

Don Soifer:
Yeah. So microschools are innovative small multifamily learning environments that serve school aged kids, right? The people that are doing early childhood education are doing crucial work. But that’s not the work that we do different. You know, we sort of push back against lawmakers that want to have too many definitions because this is still so innovative. Right. And so early, early adoption. 

Marlin Detweiler:
It’s the Wild West, of lots of things that fall under the label.

Don Soifer:
Right. There is I mean, multi age small single classroom. Schools are not new, right. I mean, the earliest western versions of a school where I don’t know what the book of judges, something like that. And every culture has a version of that.

Marlin Detweiler:
Well, if you come visit me in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, where I live some of the year, I can take you to one room schoolhouses, which sounds to me like they’re a form of a microschool.

Don Soifer:
Absolutely. When slate blackboards first came across trains in the American prairies, that was the start of what we’re doing. So some aspects of this are not new at all. But today’s movement has really taken off. We serve about a 2% market share, about a million and a half kids nationally. And it’s only begun to, you know, innovate and grow.

Marlin Detweiler:
How would you distinguish it from the term cottage school? Is that a synonym or is that something that has some different connotations?

Don Soifer:
So it’s a beautifully diversified movement in terms of the models that we see. And a lot of cottage schools will absolutely identify as microschools. So will some larger entities. So sometimes we have provider networks that are connected in different ways. But absolutely, cottage schools are the spirit and lifeblood of so much of what we do.

Marlin Detweiler:
Okay. When we got involved in classical Christian education in 1993, and then in 95, after a couple of years of birthing with others, of course, the Geneva School, which is a full fledged five day classical Christian school, we determined that we needed to move to from Orlando to Lancaster, the area that I grew up in.

And so because we plan to go back and forth, we knew that would be fairly disruptive to the children and the school if they were at the classical school that we started. And so we decided to homeschool them along with another family. We had four boys. They had two. So every day my wife and Michelle Watt, another mother, got together.

Michelle was a CPA. My wife is a real creative, a writer and that sort of thing. And they split what they taught according to their strengths, to all six of these young boys. Is that another version of a microschool?

Don Soifer:
So with a microschool, you really have the opportunity to design and run your microschool around the specific needs of the particular kids that you’re serving and really meet them where they are and they’re learning trajectory. I sort of call that an active learner trajectory. So you have the opportunity to do that. And that’s what’s so exciting to families, urban and rural and, you know, we do very well at the fragile end of the income spectrum for families that are just not sure that their state’s public school frameworks and curriculum are the best way to prepare the kid for their future, that they’re going to have. What you describe fits right into this movement. 

Marlin Detweiler:
What is it that captured your imagination to help spearhead and help catalyze growth here? 

Don Soifer:
So not nothing really meaningful in education happens in a vacuum, right? And look at the, you know, the future that we’re preparing our kids, our own high schoolers to succeed in now. And it’s you know, you look at the traditional large factory school model that was created in the mid 20th century to serve the needs of an economy, right, that existed then that’s so different than the new economy that’s already here now.

And the durable skills and everything that’s going to be necessary for our kids when they go out into the world right away to prepare them for success. And I think that the business of, you know, moving schooling out of buildings that in this country are an average 50 years old and cost 50 to $100 million, feels a lot more like the economies of the mid 20th century than it does for right now. And we find this, you know, that a very exciting opportunity. Yeah.

Marlin Detweiler:
This might be jumping ahead a little bit, so I’ll probably have some questions that will fill in behind this. But who are the people that you find enjoy most and succeed most with something? You know, what I’m seeing is that we see things on a continuum from the pure homeschooler, on one extreme who doesn’t? They’ll buy some things, they’ll use curriculum, but they’re going to keep they’re going to teach everything to their own children.

They’re going to have very limited contact with other outside resources online and that sort of thing. And then you have people who venture out a little bit more and they might be part of a homeschool co-op, they might be part of an online school taking classes and that sort of thing. And there are several different places along that continuum to the full fledged brick and mortar, five day a week school under a continuum that says, how do you ask the question, how do you educate your children?

You fall in, I guess, somewhere beyond the online experience, although maybe it runs in parallel in some sense. But who are the people that you find benefit most from taking on a small group approach with children in the form of what falls under your microschool model?

Don Soifer:
Sure. So my organization, the National microschool Center, does a study every year, a sector analysis. And just to I won’t throw numbers at you, but just to give you a general sense of how it fits in. More than half of all my school founders are formerly or currently licensed educators in their state. About a third of microschool founders have their own kids that they want to include in their own microschool.

And, you know, we do sort of a lot beyond that. Right. microschool founders I really think of as the local leaders that America needs. Right. And not just now has always needed. And they’re the most successful microschools are very plugged into their communities and the needs of families in their communities so that they can, you know, have a good sense of their likelihood to succeed with the populations that they’re looking to serve.

But you don’t know what the needs and the needs of any kids learning evolve to as that kid grows older. So these are so microschools. We see a median size of about 20 kids per microschool. They start smaller than that. And they can operate in, you know, a straight up commercial lease on a former retail spaces, you know, a popular arrangement.

But microschools operate in homes operating, you know, they can be larger than that as well. We the organization that leads the nation’s independent private schools did a study recently about microschools. And they said these things are really inexpensive. We could never do that. Right. And it’s understandable that those good people would think.

Marlin Detweiler:
Real estate cost is a big difference. And the teacher cost two of the three major costs are much reduced in most situations, aren’t they?

Don Soifer:
Yeah. And you know, the growth of a microschool community in any area has two main drivers. We see the frameworks that they need to operate within the state. Right. Some states have very regulated private school laws or homeschool laws. And then, you know, school choice possibilities. But we love our microschools in the blue states every bit as much as in the red states and some of the most innovative stuff we see, and also in the demand and interest within a community.

So whether it’s a rural community or an urban community and sort of everything in between, we’re seeing so that, you know, we do from time to time this time of year, hear from lawmakers that want to have a definition of microschools for their own purposes. Right. And there can be value in that. And in terms of being an allowable use for school choice program.

Dollars for one. But the minute you have a government label, you’ve got a bull’s eye on your back to be regulated, which some folks are very interested in. But at the end of the day, this is such a fast, innovating community that there’s not a consensus within microschooling for what that definition would even look like, because the innovating is far from done.

Marlin Detweiler:
So from a student side, who are the students that thrive most in a microschool environment? Yeah. Describe the character of those kids.

Don Soifer:
For sure. So you would say that microschools as a movement have an enrollment preference for kids that could be thriving more than they were in their prior setting for kids who have been underserved in one way or another. So we have a, you know, we have a larger population of children with special needs or neurodiversity, for sure, but that can include lots of kids.

So when we do a lot of work with helping microschools measure their impact. And we need to factor that in. Right? Because snapshot proficiency and mastery rates, we celebrate when we get low baseline assessment for our kids when our kids come in underperforming. But when it comes to the growth, academic growth and the nonacademic growth, which is fascinating of individual kids over time microschools, I put up against anybody when it comes to that.

It is important to, you know, one of the things our study this past year turned out is that pre-launch microschool founders cared more about nine academic growth than about academic growth at all, which is an incredible indication of where the sector is going and where parents want it to go.

Marlin Detweiler:
Is that a result of more individual attention? Probably based on a, I noticed you use the term learning guide in some situation. I think you use that Nevada, but I’m going to call it a teacher because we all know what it is and I understand the form and substance arguments. Is that because of student-teacher ratios? And being able to provide individual attention.

Don Soifer:
So parents choose a particular microschool for the kid for a large number of different reasons, as you would understand. And kids tend to feel seen and feel heard in a microschool more than they had in their prior environment, which is something that you can do in a small learning environment. And so many teachers come to microschools from much more traditional classrooms where they’ll say to us all the time, I got tired of having to kick my classroom door closed so that I could teach the way that I knew that my kids needed me to teach to them.

And understanding, you know, working with the families to be an active partner in the decisions that matter to that kids learning is attractive to the educator as well as to the family as someone that’s been on both sides of that.

Marlin Detweiler:
Yeah. I think it’s true that in all forms of what I’ll call non-government school education, the family is more welcomed in many public schools, government schools, families, parents are not particularly welcomed. And I would expect, since this is kind of by the parents with the parents. That this is going to be a good extreme of parental involvement.

Don Soifer:
It is. Right. It depending on the state that you’re in, you know, whether it makes sense to organize as a private school or as a sort of a, you know, a learning center serving families that follow the homeschool rules of your state are not lazy homeschool parents by any means, right? It just makes there’s an awful lot more that’s possible in this golden age of digital content.

There’s a lot of support that you can get. And leading the microschool, especially as the kids get into the high school years, which can be in more intimidating for some. But the you know, we have microschools that don’t use screen time at all. And certainly the faith based attraction is crucial to so much of this base of families that we serve in what’s important to them. And you can do all of that in a school, in a flexible environment.

Marlin Detweiler:
What was it in your case in the Las Vegas, Nevada area? Many people don’t realize, but there is a real residential aspect to Las Vegas. It’s not all the Las Vegas gambling strip. And in your case, you worked in a public private partnership. Tell us a little bit about what distinguishes that from, say, school choice elements or maybe even the public schools.

Don Soifer:
Yeah. It’s fascinating in so many ways. When we started doing this, first of all, we were working with all elected Democrats in the city of North Las Vegas. So, they, when everything shut down around them and they had first responders and city employees that they had to provide for, in some ways we were competing with your kid being left alone with a jar of peanut butter.

Right. And the city recognized that the city was a fantastic. So partnership microschool was are crucial to this movement.

Marlin Detweiler:
Just parenthetically, was it because of the shutdown and the extreme work of first responders as a result that was a motivating factor? And that’s one of the reasons that there was an initial focus on first responders’ kids.

Don Soifer:
Yeah, for the city leaders, for sure. Right. They were responding to pressing urgent needs within their community was as good leaders will do. Yeah. And so we had to create so learn. So we were probably more focused on addressing learning loss and academic growth than we otherwise would be in our own microschool. But that was important to the city because taxpayer dollars were going to it, and they needed to show that the taxpayer was having a good deal.

You know, we were being good stewards of the taxpayer dollars, which I appreciated. But the mayor stood out, stood up and said that our program, we also at the time created a program to serve the kids that stayed in the public school district. You know, they were doing their distance learning. That obviously wasn’t going very well nationally, but that they could come.

You know, we set aside a program for them as well. And the city team was able to provide us free breakfast and free lunch and facilities. It was a great model overall, but the city made our program free for all residents that withdrew from the school district and became homeschoolers. And, you know, with our supports and the relationships that we built with families to give them the confidence to do that, it made it a pretty unique program.

Marlin Detweiler:
Yeah, that is unique. For the Christian, for the people who are independent of the public schools, you have categorized microschools as an independent microschool, which isn’t getting funded by dollars that way. Now we have things, like ESA funds and the coming up educational freedom tax credit, funding for school choice.

How will that affect the microschool initiative, the movement? Yeah. So there are 11 states now that microschools are able to participate in the state school choice programs with different, you know, with different things that they need to comply with. And many microschool founders choose to not be private schools because of the regulation that comes with that. Often that’s seen as time requirements or hiring restrictions. So, the details of a program matter for sure.

Don Soifer:
But the difference in the landscape between Pennsylvania and Florida, the two states that we’re talking about are really different. And Pennsylvania has got an important case going on right now where it’s a good example because the child care regulators, which is a whole other bucket of regulation that come in, even though we’re serving school age kids and not preschool aged kids aren’t quite sure, or the fire marshal doesn’t quite know how it is that they need to, you know, which handbook do they show up when they need to regulate?

I mean, if you operate a hardware store, that facility does not have no regulation behind it. The fire marshal has something to say about that, you know, so we’ve got different solutions in different states for the ways that that can look. But in terms of the economics of the thing, I mean, again, we even in the blue and purple states where there are no school choice programs coming anytime soon or those that might not have opted into the new federal scholarship tax credit program itself, partnerships can be crucial.

Don Soifer:
So, like what we did in North Las Vegas, we have partnerships nationally between YMCA and rural libraries and goodwill stores. All sorts of good nonprofit community organizations can help be the host partner. And you talked about churches and other houses of worship. How many churches have three classrooms that are pretty free during the week? So whether or not it’s affiliated with the ways that the church serves its congregation, whether or not it’s affiliated as part of the mission of the church or in some cases, not, it can be a crucial way to bring families together and help fulfill the goals of that community of faith with, you know, within their broader community. And it’s exciting to watch the different ways that can look.

Marlin Detweiler:
One of the things that I’ve observed in my consultation work with start up classical Christian schools as they come along, is most of the problems tend to be at the higher level with governance in the board, and that sort of thing. Is that the case here also? What kind of governance models have you seen successful? What are the typical governance models?

Don Soifer:
Thanks for asking about governance models. That’s crucial to this work. So depending on the state that you’re in, there are advantages in some cases to being a nonprofit. And then you deal with the IRS in that world of regulations, although in some cases it’s harder to get a bank loan if to get startup if you’re a nonprofit, they would rather work with a straight up ownership arrangement.

And, you know, in other states there are different for some of the categories of school choice funding. Sometimes being in nonprofit is required, sometimes it’s not. Many microschools will just start out with an owner or a family. Sometimes they’ll set up an LLC, which can be another level of complexity added to it. But so many microschools are led by an educator who just left their classroom but hasn’t left their profession.

And they can start up serving, you know, two other kids and two of their own kids and start in a simple way, and they can make a more elaborate funding model. And we do things like help train the boards of microschools along the way, because the board can be a useful thing, or an advisory board can be a useful tool to a founder as well.

But there’s lots of ways that you can make this work. Understanding the needs and the requirements within your particular state. And sometimes the employment rules can matter as well. So understanding those are important and we’re more than happy to help microschools do that. We are nonprofit so we don’t charge them anything to do that. And then coming up with the best governance model that works for what you’re trying to accomplish.

And if growth is part of that, it’s not always part of that. But being thoughtful about that from the beginning is something you’ll thank yourself for later. As you just pointed out.

Marlin Detweiler:
So going back to what are the places that concerns come up? What are the pitfalls if people are interested in doing this? What do they need to be aware of?

Don Soifer:
Yeah. So, we strongly encourage microschools to have insurance coverage and, you know, starting with general liability insurance. And then depending on the facility that you use and facilities. The biggest barrier right now to microschooling growth as a movement is that local level of government, right. The business license approval and the zoning and the land use and getting your facility approved to operate a microschool.

And we need to go through a process of modernizing that regulatory apparatus because it had never anticipated it was created for a way of doing things that hadn’t anticipated this movement getting as popular as it is now. So those are some of the barriers and hurdles that we see. And then as a microschool grows, you know, the IRS is very serious about the employer versus contractor.

And some states have different requirements regarding that. And those are some of the barriers. And then as we see, if you want to be a private school, if you need to be a private school to participate in a school choice program, what are the requirements that come with that? Those vary differently from state to state. So understanding those isn’t really hard to do, but it’s an important first step.

Marlin Detweiler:
With the coming Educational Freedom tax credit, it’s not available to the homeschool world. It’s available to the school world.

Don Soifer:
That’s right.

Marlin Detweiler:
And so you have a designation consideration in light of state law, I guess it becomes a balancing act.

Don Soifer:
Yeah. So just this week, the president of Homeschool Legal Defense Association, which has been a valuable ally in lots of places over time, just came out and said, no, homeschoolers should absolutely qualify for that. And it’s as a, you know, as a policy person that’s been involved with this since it was in front of Congress and the Senate.

I think that the language that the lawmakers chose is broad language that should make those arrangements possible. But that’s not the way that the current Treasury Department oversight has seen it. 

Marlin Detweiler:
Way it’s being interpreted, but that’s probably something that’s going to get fleshed out. Is that what you’re saying?

Don Soifer:
That’s right. And there being smart lawyers about this. Right. They need to have something that is likely to be challenged in court and is going to need to withstand scrutiny. And they don’t want it to get thrown out. But at the end of the day, the Treasury, the US Treasury Department, has said it’s going to be coming down to what the laws in each state permit in terms of what the definition of a school is.

And I have a feeling that they’re going to probably land on schooling. I mean, we’re the National microschooling Center for a reason, right? It looks different in different states. Yeah.

Marlin Detweiler:
Interesting. What are other things that you would think our listeners would want to know as they look at many of, I would say most of our audience homeschools, we do a lot of, we have a lot of interaction with classical Christian schools, but overwhelmingly we deal with the homeschool community. What are the things that they would want to know as they consider maybe I see it, locking arms with their neighbor and getting together to kind of help each other out.

But I think of a microschool, if that’s understating it, you should correct that and then talk about the things that they would want to know as they consider what they’re doing.

Don Soifer:
Wonderful. And Marlin, you know, of which you speak, your family has done this yourselves.

Marlin Detweiler:
Well, we’ve been around the block a few times. I’ve been around education now for goodness. Three and a half decades. 

Don Soifer:
So our movement, the lifeblood of our movement, is people that aren’t sitting around waiting for the government to solve our problems for us. We can do it better ourselves and our group, the National Center, has trained in, prepared more people to launch microschools than anybody else has all over the country. And the answer is you can do this.

You know, getting good sense of what you need to do. And you know, when we started our microschool, we did. We served 125 kids on two weeks notice. And I don’t recommend that necessarily, but I come, you know, I used to be a spent over a decade of my life as a charter school authorizer that tells you you need 18 to 24 months of planning before you can start these things.

And this is just a fundamentally different way of doing schooling. So, understanding starting with understanding what the needs of your families are and the needs of the particular kids that you’re looking to serve is crucial, right? The best microschools are absolutely plugged into those. And beyond that, everything is solvable. I mean, some states are going to have barriers that you’re not going to have in other states.

I would say build relationships with other people. And, you know, the governing officials of your town will appreciate you having done that to make it easier for them to help you do it. But maybe they don’t. Maybe they’re not in it to help you do what you want to do, and maybe you’re willing to be permissionless in doing that.

Marlin Detweiler:
What do you do for people interested in seeking your help?

Don Soifer:
Yeah. So we’re a nonprofit. We’re foundation backed. So we do have a membership you can join for 100 bucks a year. And that includes all of the members of your team. And you can come to all of our programs, but we, you don’t need it’s not required to be a member of the National microschooling Center, but you get access to a few more things if you are.

We run all sorts of professional learning opportunities. We have the National microschooling Center Training Institute. That’s a hybrid program of right now it’s eight different courses that you can take with ways of learning things that are useful to you to run your school, that were not useful to a teacher, going through teacher’s college when they were learning to run a traditional classroom of 30 kids.

Every aspect of that. We have office hours from our team. Every member of our team has run a microschool or currently runs a microschool. So you can learn from somebody alongside, you know, as a cohort. We run professional learning opportunities. We have a packed schedule of online events. We work around the country. In the next few weeks, I’m going to be in around cities in Texas and we’re running a training in Nashville.

So we’ve got a team around the country, and you’re in great company. And so we’ve got an active sort of platform of founders that they’re so supportive of. One of the things I love so much about this movement is we’re in it to help each other. We really a microschool will do better.

And we like to sort of we call it an ecosystem growing environment. It’s great if you can have another microschool within a short driving distance of your own, so that maybe they’re a better match for different siblings within the same family. And maybe, you know, the different microschools in a community can help you afford a substitute teacher or share other resources like microschools, whatever it is that you want to do and sort of connecting people with that and any aspect of it.

We’re doing centered and I’m not selling you anything, we’re just there to help this movement grow.

Marlin Detweiler:
Yeah, well, it really does provide the form for any number of substance approaches to or pedagogical approaches to education. You’re providing a way for families to support each other. 

Don Soifer:
We’re at about a 2% market share nationally, which is about where Catholic schools are in this country. And it wouldn’t shock me if before all is said and done in the near term, we were closer to a 10% market share. We’re probably not going to replace Friday Night Lights in communities you know anywhere, anytime soon, but this is a vibrant community of families that just feels so crucial to the fabric of this country. It makes me feel great every day.

Marlin Detweiler:
Well, Don, thank you for what you’re doing. Thank you for joining us today.

Don Soifer:
It’s a real pleasure.

Marlin Detweiler:
Thank you. And folks, thank you for joining us on this another episode of Veritas Vox, the voice of classical Christian education. We hope to see you next time.